Spruce, pine, or fir? That is the Christmastime question. Every year, those who are loyal to an authentic evergreen Christmas tree debate the merits of which type of tree to bring into their home. And the truth is, there’s no one right answer. Every variety has its pros and cons, so the evergreen that will best suit your needs will really depend on your priorities. Is your prerogative a grand, full tree with lots of room to hang lots of jolly lights and garlands? Or perhaps you need a strong Christmas tree to support a trove of heavy, vintage ornaments. On the contrary, maybe it’s just not Christmas in your household without that evergreen aroma wafting through the decked halls. Or are you an eager decorator in need of a tree that will last from November first through Epiphany? 

No matter how your preferences rank, we’ve got you covered. We’ve rated four of the most popular evergreens—Fraser fir, Douglas fir, white pine, and Colorado blue spruce—on their fullness, strength, fragrance, and longevity out of four, with four being the best performance. Here’s how these favorite evergreens measure up.

Fraser Fir 

  • Fullness: 3 Strength: 4 Fragrance: 4Longevity: 4

This Southern native, which grows naturally only in the Appalachians, is a fave for a reason. With tidy branches and short, sturdy needles that stay put longer than most, it can handle large ornaments and transports well

Douglas Fir

  • Fullness: 3Strength: 2 Fragrance: 4Longevity: 4

Like other firs, this West Coast kind features an attractive blue-green color and excellent foliage retention. Slightly longer needles boost its fullness, but avoid hanging heavier ornaments on its more delicate branches.

White Pine

  • Fullness: 4Strength: 2 Fragrance: 1Longevity: 4

This classic Christmas tree is widely beloved for its long and shaggy needles that make for an especially plush display. But if a nice scent is what you are looking for, pines tend to pale in comparison to firs. 

Colorado Blue Spruce

  • Fullness: 3Strength: 3 Fragrance: 2Longevity: 3

A popular nontraditional tree for its attractive icy blue hue, this Rocky Mountain species has a symmetrical form, stiff branches, and a piney scent (though resin from damaged branches can cause it to smell sour). Heed the sharp needles!