While the creator sells a variety of handmade velvet pumpkins, many shoppers are opting for this custom bundle because of the ability to mix and match the colors in each set. Reviewers say the shades are not only “vibrant” and “gorgeous” in person, but also “very accurate” compared to the photos on the product page. Others rave about the “amazing quality” of the pumpkins, saying they’re “crafted extremely well.”

BUY IT: Starting at $39.99; amazon.com

Another wrote, “I wanted pumpkins without it feeling like Halloween. These are nicely made and the stems are sturdy and not flimsy at all. The seller does a wonderful, quality job on these pumpkins and I would recommend to anyone who wants to spark up their fall/winter decor with something unique.”

If you’re looking for something a little bigger, customers also recommend the bundle of three Large Velvet Pumpkins from Your Hearts Content. Crafted with the same quality and care as the seller’s smaller set, the decorative pumpkins come in rust, gold, and olive hues. (Keep in mind that this one doesn’t give you the option to select colors.)

BUY IT: $39.99; amazon.com